ABI Research: MIDs as Smartphones? 50% said yes!

Posted on 03 February 2009, Last updated on 03 February 2009 by

This one has surprised me a little bit. I expect a certain type of MID to merge with the rising capabilities of smartphones but I didn’t expect 50% of people to agree that MIDs (ABI seems to point to big-screen devices that aren’t 24/7 devices) would be cell phone replacements. Have I been a bit short-sighted here? Are we getting to a point where a 4" or even 5" screen MID with voice capabilities would be acceptable as a smartphone by a significant number of people?

MIDs have been proposed by some as cell phone replacements. Does the public agree? In this survey, almost half did, lending support to models incorporating cellular voice, while 34% said they would continue to use a cellular handset.

“This is going to become a question for MID vendors and consumers alike,” says Philip Solis, principal analyst at ABI Research. “There will be little difference between a smartphone such as the Palm Pre which uses an OMAP 3 processor and a MID with cellular voice, except for screen size. Understanding of what consumers want from stand-alone MIDs without cellular voice will be important.”

The survey was done in the U.S. where, in my experience, there’s more acceptance, or even a demand for ever bigger mobile computing products and I know there are people reading UMPCPortal that are waiting for the all-in-one to appear. I may be underestimating this part of the market. Maybe ‘MID’ is the new ‘smartphone’? On the other hand, do the ‘public’ really know what a MID is?

ABI research press release.

21 Comments For This Post

  1. Steve 'Chippy' Paine says:

    Posted a new article: ABI Research: MIDs as Smartphones? 50% said yes! http://tinyurl.com/ak66yp

  2. TDFS says:

    Wow! What an impressive revelation!

    Hey, anybody knows about hot water? Oh, wait, I’ve an other great news for you: the wheel! The wheel is a…

    Come on, it’s ridiculous that first MID on the market do not already implement it, at least using a BT headset considering that nobody would call with a 5″ thing on his face. :)

  3. TDFS says:

    Oh, of course it was not for you Steve, you do a great work! It’s for Intel and similar… You know what I think :P

  4. turn.self.off says:

    on the BT headset thing, have you seen the comments on engadget each time they present a headset?

    the only one that have gotten a somewhat favorable comment is the jawbone, and i suspect thats because they piggy backed on the iphone hype…

  5. TDFS says:

    LoL, this is interesting. Generally I don’t have time to read comments but I’ll do :)
    Actually if my MID would also call and send sms I think it would be a great thing. It’s 3G and it’s really a pity it can’t call… also a GSM modules is hilariously cheap :)

    Of course I would not put a 5″ device on my face, at least, not in public :) so and headset is the only solution as far as I know. I’m not the kind of man always wearing a BT headset, I don’t like it, but it’s pretty usefull in car.

  6. Chad W Smith says:

    As a former N800 owner, I can absolutely say yes, I’d go for a MID with cellular voice service. I just got a used 1G iPod Touch, and I wish I could just trade it in for an iPhone. Having an all-in-one device is the dream. Call it a super-smart-phone, a MID with voice, a UMPCell, a WiFi enabled PMP with 3G VOIP – I don’t care – I want it.

    A CPU powerful enough to give me the true – full Internet, with Flash
    A GPU powerful enough for 3D games – PSP level or better
    Enough storage for games, movies, and music
    800 x 480 res or higher
    4″ touchscreen
    QWERTY thumb keypad
    3MP camera (that can do stills, and video)
    Thin and lightweight
    3G with tethering
    BlueTooth
    WiFi G
    USB 2.0 in and out
    game controls would be a plus
    GPS
    accelerometer
    video out (possibly through USB? think PSP Slim style)
    I’d buy it. Name your price.

  7. Chippy says:

    Sounds like the next Nokia Internet Tablet apart from the voice requirement.

    ARMs licencees are talking about mids with voice. Ti especially.

  8. John in Norway says:

    I’ve just carried out a survey of my own and guess what? 100% of the people I surveyed said they may be or are, or maybe will be, thinking that surveys can be made to say whatever point of view the surveyer wants them to say!

    Anyway, I have no problem sticking something big against my ear, I had a Jasjar for many months. What does it matter?

  9. Chippy says:

    Nice one John.

  10. turn.self.off says:

    i would say something the size and, more importantly, weight of a N800 is the upper limit of what i would care to hold as a handset…

  11. Chad says:

    I totally agree… With a BT headset the size is almost a moot point as long as it is pockatable or easily carryable. Also since I am most likely gonig to have a sim card for 3G data I may as well use use it for voice as well.
    I hate that my iPhone has a perfectly good 3G data connection yet I still need a seperate data contract for my laptop’s data card.

  12. Realty says:

    Just a reminder that the headset would not have to just be an ear piece. It could be an entire, super thin, bluetooth handset which when done then slides into a slot in the MID. It could be very small and thin because all the brains would be in the MID.

  13. turn.self.off says:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch%3fv=IX-gTobCJHs

  14. Chippy says:

    …Or it could be a normal mobile-phone-style device. I’ve been looking for a BT device that looked like a small mobile phone for a while.

  15. turn.self.off says:

    http://www.thinkgeek.com/gadgets/cellphone/8928/

  16. Will says:

    With a BT or wired headset it is possible. I know Tadd from Msmobiles has used the HTC Advantage (5″ WinMo device) as a phone with a BT headset.

  17. Dave P says:

    I would love it if my OQO could also serve as phone via a bluetooth headset. The problem I would see is battery life. A phone needs to be always on to receive calls and text messages. I would hope this could be handled by a next-gen CPU.

    Ultimately, as technology improves, I could see speech recognition (via the bluetooth headset) replacing the keyboard for text input and the screen becoming a separate unit communicating with the GPU via bluetooth 3.0. The processors and battery would become a pocketable brick which you would only take out to recharge.

  18. Rich says:

    If MIDs are connected with wifi/3g then you can use voip for voice, so aren’t all MIDs voice capable anyway? The new Nokia tablet will have 3g, thus voip and video calling.

    Do requirements/ restrictions for devices change if voice is included, rather than just data? i.e. testing, legal stuff, network lock down? If so what you like about a MID, mini computer/ internet, may change by adding voice.

  19. Rajesh says:

    NVIDIA’s Tegra based phones will do all the things mentioned by Chad

  20. Al says:

    MIDS need cell phone abilities if they are going to find a market as the mobile phones are able to just about the same now.

    To me what I’d rather see is a pocket size MID/UMPC that runs full windows, has a touch type keyboard, and still will fit in a jacket pocket when folded.

  21. Free Gadget says:

    Thanks for the info… RSS feed added

Find ultra mobile PCs, Ultrabooks, Netbooks and handhelds PCs quickly using the following links:

Acer C740
11.6" Intel Celeron 3205U
Acer Aspire Switch 10
10.1" Intel Atom Z3745
HP Elitebook 820 G2
12.5" Intel Core i5 5300U
Acer Aspire E11 ES1
11.6" Intel Celeron N2840
Acer C720 Chromebook
11.6" Intel Celeron 2955U
ASUS Zenbook UX305
13.3" Intel Core M 5Y10a
Dell Latitude E7440
14" Intel Core i5-4200U
Lenovo Thinkpad X220
12.5" Intel Core i5
Acer Chromebook 11 CB3-131
11.6" Intel Celeron N2807
Lenovo Ideapad Flex 10
10.1" Intel Celeron N2806